Product Safety Complaint in Romania: What a Seller Should Do Before a Recall
Romanian business counsel · Product safety and supplier contracts
A customer reports that a product sold by your Romanian business may be unsafe. The immediate decisions concern affected stock, consumer protection, authority notification and evidence. Your supply contract then determines which costs you may be able to recover from another party.
In brief: Identify the product, reported hazard, affected batches and your actual role in the supply chain. Assess the applicable safety rules and take required protective measures and notifications promptly. A withdrawal stops affected products moving through distribution; a recall seeks the return of products already supplied to consumers. Contractual cost allocation does not replace statutory duties. Preserve one incident file and coordinate legal, technical and operational work.
This guide is for retailers, distributors and importers managing consumer-product safety concerns in Romania. Food, medicines and other excluded or specially regulated categories need their own framework. “Before a recall” means preparing the response, not postponing a recall or notification that is already required.
Need a product-incident review?
Atrium can review the complaint, authority correspondence, supply agreement and available product records to identify legal responsibilities, notice requirements and contractual exposure.
Is this a customer dispute or a product-safety incident?
A poor-quality item, late delivery and a potentially dangerous product raise different questions. A request for a refund does not exclude a safety issue: read what happened, how the product was used and whether injury, overheating, breakage, choking or another hazard is reported.
Preserve the original message, photographs, product identifiers, purchase details and the first response. Separate reported facts from verified findings. A technical specialist should assess the hazard and possible causes; counsel should identify the applicable duties and the response required from your company. Do not require multiple complaints or a completed laboratory report before considering measures justified by the information already available.
Product Incident Response Navigator
Select the signal your business received. The panel shows the first documents and decisions to review.
Customer safety complaint
Preserve the complaint and identify the product, batch, reported hazard and sales channels. Assess protective measures and any immediate notification duty against the information available.
- Complaint, photographs and purchase record.
- Product identification, instructions and supplier contact.
- Decision log recording facts, uncertainties and actions.
This navigator organises a review. It does not classify product risk or determine whether a recall or notification is legally required.
Which product-safety rules apply in Romania?
Regulation (EU) 2023/988 on general product safety, known as the GPSR, applies from 13 December 2024. Article 2 defines its scope and its relationship with product-specific EU safety rules. Identify that relationship before relying on an obligation assigned to manufacturers, importers or distributors. Consult the consolidated GPSR text for the amendments incorporated into the regulation.
For products subject to EU harmonisation legislation, Article 2 excludes specified parts of the GPSR, including Chapter III, Section 1. Consequently, Articles 9–18 are not a universal checklist for every product carrying a CE mark. For many CE-marked products, sector-specific legislation is the primary source of operator obligations. The legal classification and covered risks, rather than the CE mark alone, determine the relationship between the regimes; other GPSR provisions can remain relevant. The European Commission’s general product-safety standards page is a useful starting point for the technical framework.
Depending on the product category and issue, competence may belong to the National Authority for Consumer Protection (ANPC) or another Romanian market-surveillance authority designated under the applicable legislation. Harmonised products are not automatically outside ANPC’s remit. For example, ANCOM’s radio-equipment surveillance guidance identifies responsibilities for both ANCOM and ANPC. The Romanian medicines and medical-devices agency (ANMDMR) has a specialist market-surveillance role for medical devices.
A consumer complaint to ANPC, a business notification and a formal enforcement measure are separate procedural events. Article 44 GPSR requires Member States to establish effective, proportionate and dissuasive penalties. For an inspection or sanction, verify the Romanian provision in force, the authority’s competence, the alleged breach and the applicable challenge deadline; the GPSR does not supply a single Romanian fine schedule.
Does being “only the retailer” remove responsibility?
No. Under the applicable framework, a retailer may be a distributor with its own duties. A Romanian company placing a product from a third country on the EU market may be an importer. Under Article 13 GPSR, placing a product on the market under your own name or trademark can bring manufacturer obligations; substantial modification has its own conditions.
Where Article 12 GPSR applies: paragraph (3) requires a distributor to withhold a product it considers or has reason to believe is dangerous or fails the specified requirements until it is brought into conformity. Paragraph (4) addresses a product already made available: the distributor must immediately inform the manufacturer or importer, ensure appropriate corrective measures and ensure immediate notification of the relevant market-surveillance authorities through the Safety Business Gateway. The authority-notification duty is in Article 12(4)(c).
That provision also covers the identification and safety-information requirements expressly listed there. A failure in those requirements is not, by itself, proof of a physical hazard. Determine the non-compliance and appropriate corrective measures; do not assume every missing label requires a consumer recall.
The Commission’s Safety Business Gateway guidelines explain that, for the distributor route, the manufacturer or importer may submit the information, but the distributor must do so if they have not. Retain evidence of the actual submission and its scope. An email asking the supplier to “handle compliance” does not demonstrate that notification occurred.
What if the manufacturer is outside the EU?
Identify the actual importer and the EU responsible economic operator before relying on a foreign supplier’s assurances. For non-harmonised consumer products where Article 16 GPSR applies, the product must have an operator established in the EU responsible for the specified tasks. The eligible roles are identified through Article 4(2) of Regulation (EU) 2019/1020 on market surveillance: an EU manufacturer, an importer where the manufacturer is outside the EU, a duly mandated authorised representative, or a fulfilment service provider in the circumstances specified there.
These roles are not interchangeable. A distributor does not automatically become the importer, and naming a responsible person does not remove other operators’ own duties. For harmonised products, check the sector rules and the applicable requirements of Regulation 2019/1020, rather than applying Article 16 GPSR indiscriminately.
What is the difference between withdrawal and recall?
Withdrawal: control distribution
Article 3 GPSR defines withdrawal by reference to preventing a product in the supply chain from being made available on the market. Identify warehouse stock, goods in transit, store inventory and active online offers.
Implement and record the relevant stock and sales controls. A listing removed from one website does not establish that every sales channel is controlled.
Recall: reach consumers
A recall aims to obtain the return of a product already supplied to consumers. It requires a workable identification, communication and remedy process.
Some incidents require both withdrawal of remaining inventory and recall of sold units. The correct measures depend on the risk, distribution history and applicable law.
Can you trace the affected batch through the business?
Build a product-specific distribution record. Connect supplier identifiers to internal stock codes, shipment records, stores, online orders and customer contact information lawfully held. Record uncertain quantities explicitly; avoid presenting a partial stock search as a complete batch reconciliation.
Use consumer contact data to the extent necessary for safety communications and handle it under the General Data Protection Regulation (GDPR). Article 35(1) GPSR requires economic operators and, where applicable, online marketplaces collecting customer personal data to use that information for recalls and safety warnings. This supports necessary direct contact with affected customers, not unrestricted use of every item of customer data. Where processing is necessary to fulfil an applicable legal obligation, Article 6(1)(c) GDPR can provide the legal basis; that does not justify unrelated marketing or unrestricted disclosure. Keep the processing transparent, restrict access and retain the data only as justified by the applicable purpose and legal requirements.
Article 35(2) separately requires businesses with product-registration systems or loyalty programmes identifying purchases for other purposes to offer customers the option of providing separate contact details solely for safety communications.
Injury reports may include health data, which require a separate applicable condition under Article 9 GDPR as well as an Article 6 basis. Collect only necessary information, restrict access and arrange secure disclosure to advisers and authorities. Do not include identifiable medical records in a public recall notice.
Batch Traceability Explorer
Tick each stage only when its records are available for review. Copy the resulting document-gap list for your team.
0 of 4 document stages marked available.
Documents still to collect
- Supplier: product and batch identifiers, invoices and shipment records.
- Warehouse: stock reconciliation, transfers and recorded stock controls.
- Sales channels: affected listings, store allocations and order exports.
- Consumers: lawful contact route, communication log and remedy records.
Availability is not evidence that the records are complete or accurate.
Selections remain in this page and reset when it is reloaded. The tool does not upload records or verify traceability compliance.
When must the business notify authorities or report an accident?
The trigger and responsible actor depend on the product regime, your role and the information received. Where the relevant GPSR duties apply, notification can be immediate. A commercial approval process or dispute over reimbursement must not postpone a required submission.
The European Commission’s Safety Business Gateway is the business notification portal. The public Safety Gate portal provides information on dangerous products and alerts. These have different functions: searching public alerts does not submit your business notification.
Article 20 GPSR separately addresses accidents associated with product use. Paragraph (2) covers death or serious adverse effects on health and safety, whether permanent or temporary, including injury, illness and chronic health effects. Under paragraph (1), the manufacturer must ensure notification through the Safety Business Gateway to the competent authority of the Member State where the accident occurred, without undue delay from learning of it.
Under Article 20(3), importers and distributors that know of an accident caused by a product they placed or made available on the market must inform the manufacturer without undue delay. The manufacturer must notify under paragraph (1) or instruct the importer or one of the distributors to notify. Where the manufacturer is outside the EU, paragraph (4) requires the responsible person within Article 16(1) GPSR or Article 4(1) of Regulation 2019/1020, if aware of the accident, to ensure notification. Verify the reporting actor, timeline and authority against the product regime and facts. A separate dangerous-product notification may be required even where no accident or injury has occurred.
Keep the notification record
Identify the submitting entity, products, countries, reported risk, measures and updates. Keep the submission confirmation and correspondence. If quantities or findings change, coordinate the necessary updates rather than leaving incompatible versions with different authorities.
What must a consumer-facing recall communication contain?
Under Article 35 GPSR, affected consumers who can be identified must be notified directly and without undue delay, according to the actors’ respective obligations. Where direct contact cannot reach everyone, use appropriate additional channels to achieve the widest possible reach.
Article 36 governs written recall notices, including identification of the product and hazard, the action consumers should take, available remedies and a contact route. Use the Commission’s recall-notice template under Implementing Regulation (EU) 2024/1435. Prepare the notice in the relevant languages, including Romanian for the Romanian consumer audience.
Article 36(2)(c) requires a clear hazard description and excludes wording that reduces consumers’ perception of risk, including “precautionary” and statements that no accidents have been reported. Make the product and batch identifiable without requiring the consumer to interpret an internal stock code. Provide accessible formats: important product identifiers shown in an image should also appear as machine-readable text. Ensure the contact team can explain and implement the stated remedy.
Article 37 requires the economic operator responsible for the safety recall to offer an effective, cost-free and timely remedy. As a general rule, that operator must offer a choice between at least two of repair, replacement with a safe equivalent and an adequate refund at least equal to the price paid. The limited exception for impossible or disproportionately costly remedies requires assessment under the provision’s conditions; a budget preference alone is insufficient. As an operational check, confirm that each offered option can actually be delivered through the recall process.
The remedy must not cause significant inconvenience. Consumers must not bear shipping or other return costs; for products that are not portable by their nature, the operator must arrange collection. Consumers remain entitled to a refund if repair or replacement is not completed within a reasonable time and without significant inconvenience. These logistics belong in the response plan and budget.
Are recall remedies the same as warranty or injury claims?
No. Article 37 preserves the relevant consumer sales rights. In Romania, Emergency Ordinance No. 140/2021 on consumer sales of goods provides the separate framework for conformity and remedies in the sales relationship, subject to its own conditions and time limits. Do not assume a commercial warranty period defines the limits of a product-safety recall.
Regulatory safety duties are also separate from potential civil liability for injuries or property damage caused by a defective product. Romanian Law No. 240/2004 on liability for defective products transposes Directive 85/374/EEC, as amended by Directive 1999/34/EC, and addresses that liability alongside potentially relevant contractual or non-contractual claims. Liability requires its own assessment of the defect, damage, causation and responsible parties. Recall expenditure and compensation for injury should not be treated as the same insured loss.
Directive (EU) 2024/2853 on liability for defective products sets a transposition deadline of 9 December 2026. Article 2(1), as corrected by the 7 May 2026 corrigendum, applies the directive to products placed on the market or put into service after 8 December 2026. Under Article 21, Directive 85/374/EEC is repealed with effect from 9 December 2026 but continues to apply to products placed on the market or put into service before that date. Before relying on the new regime in Romania, check whether the implementing legislation has been adopted, its effective date and the provisions applicable to the particular product and claim.
Who pays, and what should the supply agreement resolve?
Separate the immediate regulatory response from later contractual recovery. Examine the executed supply or distribution agreement, purchase orders, product specifications, insurance and notice provisions together. Responsibility for a defect and entitlement to reimbursement need evidence and an applicable contractual or legal basis.
| Cost or task | Review first | Do not assume |
|---|---|---|
| Stock and transport | Quarantine, collection, storage and return arrangements. | Every logistics cost is included in the supplier’s indemnity. |
| Testing and evidence | Expert appointment, samples, scope and access to findings. | A supplier’s short assurance resolves the technical issue. |
| Consumer remedies | Refund, replacement and repair funding; operational owner. | The lowest-cost option is always legally sufficient. |
| Communications | Notice drafting, languages, customer contact and channels. | Supplier approval can delay mandatory communication. |
| Insurance and recovery | Policy cover, exclusions, notification and evidence requirements. | Product-liability insurance necessarily covers recall costs. |
| Recovery proceedings | Governing law, jurisdiction, arbitration, limitation periods and notice deadlines. | The supplier’s location determines the forum or every claim has the same deadline. |
Send contractual notices in the agreed form and within the applicable deadlines while continuing required safety measures. Review liability caps and exclusions for enforceability. Where Romanian law applies, Article 1355(1) of the Romanian Civil Code prohibits excluding or limiting liability for material damage caused intentionally or through gross negligence. Under paragraph (3), liability for harm to physical or psychological integrity or health cannot be excluded or reduced except under the conditions provided by law. The enforceability of a particular cap or exclusion depends on the clause, the parties, the type of harm and any applicable mandatory rules. An indemnity or cap does not remove mandatory duties or automatically bind an injured consumer.
The negotiation should also address incident cooperation, data access, record retention, authority communications, reimbursement timing and disputes over causation. Our guide to negotiating a Romanian distribution agreement explains how these duties fit the wider commercial relationship.
Recall Cost & Responsibility Planner
Enter one budgeting scenario, then select Calculate. Use a weighted remedy allowance if customers may choose different remedies.
Gross scenario budget
- Consumer remedies€0.00
- Returns and handling€0.00
- Testing and communication€0.00
- Contingency€0.00
No estimate has been calculated. Enter your assumptions and select Calculate.
Formula: units × (remedy + logistics) + testing + communication, then your contingency percentage. This is a gross planning estimate, not a recall recommendation, legal fee, recoverable claim or insurance assessment. It excludes taxes, penalties, injury claims, lost sales, disposal and costs not entered. Use a consistent VAT basis for inputs; the tool does not determine VAT adjustments or deductibility. A return estimate must not limit the required scope of a recall.
Illustrative scenario: a supplier alert reaches a Romanian retailer
Hypothetical example. This is not a client matter or a reported outcome.
The information received
A Romanian retailer receives a supplier alert about a structural defect in a batch of folding chairs. Some units remain in its warehouse, some are displayed in stores and others have been sold online. The supplier offers replacement stock but asks the retailer to wait before contacting customers.
The review questions
The team identifies the applicable product regime, verifies the batch and maps sold and unsold units. It assesses the required controls, notifications and consumer communication promptly. Supplier cost negotiations proceed alongside those duties.
The contractual question
The agreement refers to “defective product replacement” without expressly addressing collection, customer contact or testing. Counsel examines whether other clauses and the governing law support recovery, and preserves notices and cost evidence.
The useful work product
A coordinated review can produce an incident chronology, responsibility map, document-gap list, reviewed notices and a contractual recovery analysis. The technical assessment and authority’s response remain separate parts of the process.
How Atrium can assist with a product-safety response
Our commercial contract review services can support the analysis of supplier responsibilities, notices, indemnities and recovery provisions. For an active incident, a defined legal mandate can also cover the applicable notification route, authority correspondence and consumer-facing documents, coordinated with your technical and operational advisers.
For the first discussion, identify the product, your role, countries of sale, allegation, any injury reported and any deadline in authority correspondence. Describe the available complaint, supplier agreement, batch records, technical findings and actions already taken. Agree a secure transfer route before sending sensitive customer or medical information.
Scope and fee: Ask for a written proposal for the initial document review or incident-response work. A starting fee or fee cap should relate to specified documents and tasks; technical testing, translations, recall logistics and separate proceedings need their own allocation. No case-specific price is stated here.
Related Guides
Identify the correspondence and build an evidence-based response.
Read the complaint guide ↗ Supplier and distributor responsibilitiesReview product duties, cooperation and contractual cost allocation.
Read the distribution guide ↗ Commercial contract reviewExplore drafting and negotiation support for your agreements.
View the service ↗Frequently asked questions
Does every product complaint require a recall?
No. The reported facts, product regime, hazard and distribution history determine the appropriate response. A quality complaint may have no safety dimension, while one credible safety report can require prompt protective action. A recall assessment should not be postponed until several customers report the same problem.
Can a retailer leave notification entirely to the supplier?
Not simply by assuming the supplier will act. Where Article 12 GPSR applies, the distributor must ensure the relevant authorities are informed. The manufacturer or importer may make the submission, but the distributor should verify it and act if it has not occurred. Product-specific rules may require a different analysis.
Who is responsible if the manufacturer is outside the EU?
Identify the importer and the EU responsible economic operator required by the applicable regime. For non-harmonised consumer products where Article 16 GPSR applies, eligible roles follow Article 4(2) of Regulation (EU) 2019/1020. A responsible person does not replace the manufacturer’s, importer’s or distributor’s own duties, and a retailer is not automatically the importer. Sector-specific rules may require a different assessment.
Is removing an online listing enough?
Removing a listing can help control further sales through that channel. It does not address warehouse stock, other listings, store inventory or products already with consumers. The response must cover the affected supply chain and any required consumer communication, remedies and notifications.
Must the supplier reimburse every recall cost?
That is not automatic. Recovery depends on the agreement, governing law, cause of the incident, evidence, notice requirements and any enforceable limits. Identify which expenses are covered and preserve the supporting records. A reimbursement dispute does not postpone mandatory product-safety measures.
Can the business offer only a refund?
Article 37 GPSR generally requires the responsible operator to offer a choice between at least two specified remedies. A single remedy can be offered under the provision’s limited impossibility or disproportionate-cost exception. The conditions need a case-specific assessment; the cheapest option is not automatically sufficient.
Does the calculator estimate legal fees or insurance recovery?
No. It totals the operational assumptions you enter for one scenario. It does not decide which remedy is lawful, whether a recall is required, what a lawyer will charge or what the supplier or insurer must pay. Those questions require separate review.
AI-assisted content.

